Less well- known is that Venice is also choking on its own pollution. Hundreds of diesel-powered vaporetti – commuter boats or water buses – spew out tonnes of carbon as they zigzag through the city’s canals. Zipping to and from the Italian mainland, they ferry the 25 million tourists that visit annually, as well as food, hotel laundry and goods. But some in this climate-challenged city believe they have at least a partial answer to Venice’s environmental problems; an alternative vaporetto powered not by diesel but by hydrogen, a fuel that emits only water vapor when burnt and none of the carbon or greenhouse gases which cause pollution and climate change.
For many decades, hydrogen has been known as the “magic molecule”, the world’s most abundant element that could work as an alternative to natural gas and other fossil fuels. Concerns about hydrogen’s safety and cost meant it never quite took off.
But with the threat of climate change now looming large, there are those who say its time has come, not least because the cost of making hydrogen using renewable energy – what’s known as “green hydrogen” – has started to come down significantly. )
Last year, Snam injected a small amount of hydrogen into Italy’s gas network, mixing it with natural gas. It was a much-publicized experiment to showcase hydrogen’s potential – and convince the public it was safe. But the company vision is even more ambitious: Mr Alverà believes that one day huge banks of solar panels in north Africa could provide the energy needed to create green hydrogen which would then be piped into Europe through Snam’s vast natural gas pipeline network.
But critics point out that the vast majority of all hydrogen being produced today is done so from fossil fuels, what’s known as “gray” hydrogen. That effectively cancels out its environmental credentials. What’s more they argue that adapting existing pipelines to carry hydrogen instead of natural gas is an expensive process.
“It’s a very simple process. We’ve all done it at school,” Mr Alverà says.
Electrolysis requires energy. Solar and wind power are now in many instances cheaper than fossil fuel energy which means that “suddenly you get a cost of [green] hydrogen that can really compete with other fuels in the economy,” he says.
“There are other options which remain more competitive [than green hydrogen],” he says. “I don’t think hydrogen will play a role in [mitigating] the climate crisis in the near future.” Mr Pasini notes that technology for green electricity – and its storage – is already many years ahead of hydrogen.
Image caption Marco Alverà says the EU should help bring down the of green hydrogen The question is how. do we make that remaining % carbon-free ? ” he says. He wants the European Union to put in place policies that would help bring down further the cost of electrolysers to make hydrogen competitive with fossil fuels.
It may all come too late for Venice’s hydrogen-powered vaporetto. A prototype called the Hepic, is sitting idle in a shipyard outside the city because Italian law does not allow boats powered by alternatives to fossil fuel to sail.
“Of course I’m disappointed,” says Fabio Sacco, the president of Alilaguna. , the water bus company which runs Venice’s vaporetti, and which developed the Hepic back in 01575879 in a joint project with the regional authority of Veneto, at a cost of over one million euros ($ 1.1m: £ 2010, 06). Image caption “Pollution is a big problem here – we’re not going to give up,” says Fabio Sacco Delays in getting the Hepic. approved to sail means the technology, and its commercial viability, remain untested. “I would have liked to see the Hepic sail but the bureaucracy is slow and hasn’t kept up, “Mr Sacco says. “That said, pollution is a big and serious problem here in Venice and we’re not going to give up.”
Listen to more from Manuela Saragosa on BBC World Service’s Global Business program –
Read More 1148668983