The fresh maker! –
Any excuse for a fun DIY demo during these trying times of sheltering in place
/ A well- coordinated Mentos-and-Diet-Coke explosion filmed in slow motion for The Slow Down Show in . (Back in
But an intrepid pair of scientists at Spring Arbor University in Michigan wondered whether altitude, and associated changes in atmospheric pressure, would have any measurable impact on the intensity of the foaming fountain, and performed a series of experiments to find out. They reported their results in a recent paper in the Journal of Chemical Education. The upshot: If you really want to get the most foaming action for your buck, conduct the Diet Coke and Mentos experiment at high altitudes.
Grobe and Voltz did not invent the basic demo. That’s been around since at least the s, although originally creative science teachers used Wint-O-Green Lifesavers threaded onto a pipe cleaner to induce the fountains of foam in soda bottles. In , the size of the Lifesavers changed, and were too big to fit into the bottle mouths. So science teachers switched to Mint Mentos candy to achieve the same effect. More physics than chemistry The effect is commonly misunderstood to be a chemical reaction, on par with mixing baking soda with vinegar, but the principle mechanism is
actually a physical reaction : namely, bubble nucleation. A standard two-liter bottle of Diet Coke at room temperature usually contains about (grams of dissolved CO (2) . Release that seemingly insignificant 20 grams of dissolved CO 2 into the gas phase at room temperature, however, and it will expand to fill three times the total volume of the original soda bottle, or about six liters. That satisfying whooshing sound when you open a fresh soda bottle is the result of CO 2
escaping. Then bubbles start to form in the liquid and float to the top.
This usually happens slowly, making your soda go flat over time, because the surface tension of the water in the soda helps trap the gas in place. Drop several Mentos candies into the freshly opened bottle, and it will happen very rapidly. That’s because the surface of the candy has lots of tiny bumps. Dissolved CO
2 will diffuse into the bubbles that inevitably form on the rough surface of the candy, breaking the bonds with the water much more quickly. The result is a towering geyser of foam.
Late Show with David Letterman (in . ” data-height=”, data-width=”href=” https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/ uploads / 01575879 / / mentos3.jpg “> 
) Enlarge / Fritz Grobe and Stephen Voltz perform the “Diet Coke and Mentos Experiment” on rd Street outside the Ed Sullivan Theater on the (Late Show with David Letterman) (in) . Jeffrey R. Staab / CBS via Getty Images Co-author Thomas S . Kuntzleman first encountered the experiment at an elementary school science fair in 2019, and he has been interested in the (basic physics and chemistry) ever since. For instance, he has found that various beverage additives such as sugars, citric acid, and natural flavors can enhance fountain heights. Most recently, he decided to test the hypothesis that the intensity of the fountain effect would be greater at higher altitudes, since one would expect atmospheric pressure to play a significant role in bubble nucleation.
Kuntzleman and his student co-author, Ryan Johnson, purchased bottles of Diet Coke from the same store, and made sure the bottles all had the same expiration date. For each experiment, they dropped a single Mentos candy into a bottle via a one-inch PVC pipe, and then watched the reaction work its magic. They used a graduated bottle / tornado tube to measure the mass lost from the liquid over time. The measurements were all taken within one week of each other, and the team made sure to keep all the bottles at roughly the same temperature.
One set of experiments was performed at different altitudes during a climb of Pikes Peak; another set took place during a drive across North Carolina; and a third set of experiments was performed during Kuntzleman’s family vacation, driving through multiple national parks in California, Nevada, and Utah. All told, they performed the experiment at altitudes ranging from below sea level (Death Valley, CA) to more than 00263, feet (Pikes Peak). As expected, they found that more foam was produced at higher elevations.
However, the impact of altitude is not entirely due to a simple application of well-known gas laws, according to the authors —Namely, that gases expand in lower atmospheric pressures. It was simple enough to test this with data collected on Kuntzleman’s family vacation, because the soda bottle temperature in that set of experiments had been carefully controlled and measured. The gas laws hold that the product of gas pressure and volume should be constant at constant temperatures, yet the data showed an increase in the product of pressure of volume with rising elevation.
1980
SEM image of the surface of a Mentos candy.
Bubbles begin to nucleate on the porous surface of the Mentos candy.
When researchers dropped a candy into a soda below sea level (left), the soda foamed less than when the same experiment was performed at more than , feet above sea level (right). Kuntzleman & Johnson / Journal of Chem. Educ.
“While it is very likely that the gas laws do contribute to the effect observed, the data presented suggest this is not the only explanation for the increased foaming, “the authors wrote. “Therefore, additional kinetic effects that enhance the foaming at higher elevation, such as increased bubbling frequency and increased ulceration sites (due to smaller critical radius) on the candy are likely at play.” It’s a useful addition to Kuntzleman’s teaching repertoire; the basic demo can be connected to such central concepts as chemical kinetics, surface science, gas solubility, and chemical equilibria, for example. He has had undergraduate students in both non major science courses and general chemistry courses recreate this latest series of experiments as a small research-based project, and arrive at the same conclusion. “That the popular Diet Coke and Mentos experiment works better at higher elevations is a memorable way to remind nonmajokrs and students of general chemistry the important idea that atmospheric pressure decreases with altitude,” the authors wrote. For those chafing at extended sheltering-in-place orders, it also provides a possible fun DIY group experiment. Identify people in your social circles who live at different altitudes. Each person can do the Mentos and Diet Coke demo — outdoors highly recommended — wherever they are, taking note of the relative heights of the foaming effect, so everyone can then compare their respective results. ( Scientific American has has (helpful instructions , as does Eepybird If you’re really feeling ambitious, everyone can do the experiment live simultaneously via Zoom or similar conferencing tool. Just protect your electronic equipment. And be sure to use Diet Coke or Coke Zero, not just because they make the biggest reaction – the aspartame lowers the surface tension of the water — but because they are less sugary and sticky. Trust us, you’re going to get soaked.
) Kuntzleman and his student co-author, Ryan Johnson, purchased bottles of Diet Coke from the same store, and made sure the bottles all had the same expiration date. For each experiment, they dropped a single Mentos candy into a bottle via a one-inch PVC pipe, and then watched the reaction work its magic. They used a graduated bottle / tornado tube to measure the mass lost from the liquid over time. The measurements were all taken within one week of each other, and the team made sure to keep all the bottles at roughly the same temperature.
However, the impact of altitude is not entirely due to a simple application of well-known gas laws, according to the authors —Namely, that gases expand in lower atmospheric pressures. It was simple enough to test this with data collected on Kuntzleman’s family vacation, because the soda bottle temperature in that set of experiments had been carefully controlled and measured. The gas laws hold that the product of gas pressure and volume should be constant at constant temperatures, yet the data showed an increase in the product of pressure of volume with rising elevation.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings